PRÁTICA COM QUESTÕES OFICIAIS
Questão 26 (2º exame) da UERJ 2024 (inglês)
Texto-base das questões 23 a 27 · 2º Exame de Qualificação
WHAT IS LIFE?
The magazine Philosophy Now asked two people, Tom Baranski and Courtney Walsh, to define what life is.
Tom Baranski from Somerset, New Jersey, believes that life is the aspect of existence that processes, acts, reacts, evaluates and evolves through growth (reproduction and metabolism). The crucial difference between life and non-life (or non-living things) is that life uses energy for physical and conscious development. Life is anything that grows and eventually dies, ceases to proliferate and be cognizant. Can we say that viruses, for example, are cognizant? Yes, insofar as they react to stimuli; but they are alive essentially because they reproduce and grow. Computers are non-living because even though they can cognize, they do not develop biologically (grow) and cannot produce offspring. It is not cognition that determines life: it is rather proliferation and maturation towards a state of death; and death occurs only to living substances.
Or is the question “What is the meaning (purpose) of life?” that is a real tough one? But Tom Baranski thinks that the meaning of life is the ideals we impose upon it, what we demand of it. The meaning of life is to: Do good, Be Good, but also to Receive Good. The foggy term in this advice, of course, is “good”; but he leaves that to the intuitive powers that we all share.
There are, of course, many intuitively clear examples of Doing Good. Most of us would avoid murdering; and most of us would refrain from other acts we find intuitively wrong. So our natural intuitions determine the meaning of life for us; and it seems for other species as well, for those intuitions resonate through much of life and give it its purpose.
On the other hand, Courtney Walsh from Farnborough, Hampshire, defines life as the eternal and unbroken flow of infinite rippling simultaneous events that by a fortuitous chain has led to this universe of elements we are all suspended in, that has somehow led to this present experience of sentient existence. Animal life (excluding that of humans) shows that life is a simple matter of being, by means of a modest routine of eating, sleeping and reproducing. Animals balance their days between these necessities, doing only what their bodies ask of them. The life of vegetation is not far from that of animals. They eat and sleep and reproduce in their own way, for the same result. So life is a beautiful and naturally harmonious borrowing of energy.
Yet we have taken it for granted. We have lost the power to simply be happy eating, sleeping, reproducing, believing we need a reason to be alive, a purpose and a goal to reach, so that on our deathbeds (something we have been made to fear) we can look back and tell ourselves we have done something with our lives. Life has lost its purpose because we have tried to give it one. The truth is that we are no more significant than the sand by the sea or the clouds in the sky. No more significant. But as significant.
No matter what your race, religion or gender, when you first step outside your door in the morning and feel the fresh air in your lungs and the morning sun on your face, you close your eyes and smile. In that moment you are feeling life as it should be.
Adaptado de philosophynow.org.
The life of vegetation is not far from that of animals. (\ell. 23)
The sentence above, which establishes a relationship between vegetation and animals’ life, could be the answer to the following question:
- AHow different are they?
- BWhich is more difficult?
- CHow distant are they?
- DWhich is longer?
Você já respondeu questões neste aparelho. Crie sua conta grátis para guardar o histórico e refazer as que errou.
Resposta salva no seu histórico.
Reportar erro na questão
Resolução comentada
A expressão “is not far from” pode indicar distância física, mas também pode ser usada em sentido figurado para estabelecer uma comparação. Aqui, Courtney Walsh compara a vida dos vegetais à dos animais, e não a localização desses seres.
O trecho decisivo, “The life of vegetation is not far from that of animals”, significa: “A vida dos vegetais não é muito diferente da dos animais”. A palavra “that” retoma “life”, evitando a repetição: a comparação é entre a vida dos vegetais e a vida dos animais.
O contexto confirma essa interpretação. A autora afirma que os animais comem, dormem e se reproduzem; em seguida, explica que os vegetais realizam essas mesmas atividades à sua maneira. Portanto, ela destaca a semelhança entre essas formas de vida.
A pergunta “How different are they?”, isto é, “Quão diferentes elas são?”, permite justamente a resposta apresentada: não são muito diferentes. As outras perguntas tratam de dificuldade, distância ou duração, aspectos que a frase não compara.
Alternativa A.
Pegadinha: A alternativa C engana pela leitura literal de “far”, que aqui expressa diferença, não distância física.
Por que as outras alternativas estão erradas
- BPergunta qual vida é mais difícil, mas a frase não compara graus de dificuldade.
- CInterpreta “far” como distância, embora a expressão indique semelhança nesse contexto.
- DPergunta qual vida é mais longa, mas a frase não compara duração.
Assuntos: Referência pronominal e pronomes, Inferência e ponto de vista do autor.
Reportar erro na resolução
Ver como caiu na prova
Fonte: UERJ 2024 · 2º Exame de Qualificação. Prova oficial ↗