PRÁTICA COM QUESTÕES OFICIAIS
Questão 14 do Einstein 2023
Read the text to answer questions from 11 to 14. · Prova I

In the late 1960s, following the Apollo 11 Moon landings, the three astronauts were waiting to be picked up inside their capsule floating in the Pacific Ocean — and they were hot and uncomfortable. NASA officials decided to make things more pleasant for their three national heroes. The downside? There was a small possibility of unleashing deadly alien microbes on Earth.
When humanity first made plans to send probes and people into space in the mid-20th Century, the issue of contamination came up. Firstly, there was the fear of “forward” contamination — the possibility that Earth-based life might accidentally hitch a ride into the cosmos. Spacecraft needed to be sterilised and carefully packaged before launch. If microbes silently moved onboard, it would confuse any attempts to detect alien life. And if there were extra-terrestrial organisms out there, we might end up inadvertently killing them with Earth-based bacteria or viruses. These concerns matter just as much today as they did back in the Space Race era.
A second concern was “back” contamination. This was the idea that astronauts, rockets or probes returning to Earth might bring back life that could prove catastrophic, either by consuming all our oxygen or outcompeting Earth organisms. What if the astronauts brought back something dangerous? At the time, the probability was not considered high, but still, the scenario had to be explored. “Maybe it’s sure to 99% that Apollo 11 will not bring back lunar organisms,” said one influential scientist at the time, “but even that 1% of uncertainty is too large to be complacent about.”
NASA put several quarantine measures in place — in some cases, a little reluctantly. Concerned officials from the US Public Health Service argued for stricter measures than initially planned, pointing out that they had the power to refuse border entry to contaminated astronauts. NASA then agreed to install a costly quarantine facility on the ship that would pick up the men from their splashdown in the Pacific Ocean. It was also agreed that the lunar explorers would then spend three weeks in isolation before they could hug their families or shake the hand of the president.
(Richard Fisher. www.bbc.com, 18.02.2021. Adapted.)
According to the third and fourth paragraphs, the disputes over the potential risks posed by the return of Apollo 11 from outer space were eventually settled as follows:
- Asevere actions were taken to guarantee enough oxygen to Apollo 11 astronauts returning to Earth.
- BNASA publicly rejected US Public Health Service recommendations over stricter Earth-entry procedures.
- CNASA hesitated to embrace quarantine measures, eventually putting astronauts’ lives in danger.
- Dback contamination was dismissed as a threat since there was only 1% certainty it could take place.
- EEarth-entry provisions were made, such as quarantine equipment and a 21-day isolation period for astronauts.
Você já respondeu questões neste aparelho. Crie sua conta grátis para guardar o histórico e refazer as que errou.
Resposta salva no seu histórico.
Reportar erro na questão
Resolução comentada
A questão pede como a disputa sobre os riscos do retorno da Apollo 11 foi resolvida, segundo os parágrafos 3 e 4.
No 3º parágrafo, o texto define a "back contamination": o medo de que astronautas ou sondas trouxessem à Terra vida perigosa. A probabilidade era baixa, mas o cientista diz que mesmo 1% de incerteza era grande demais para ficar tranquilo.
No 4º parágrafo, a NASA instalou medidas de quarentena, "in some cases, a little reluctantly" (em alguns casos, um pouco relutante). Os oficiais do US Public Health Service pediram medidas mais rígidas, e a NASA aceitou: concordou em instalar "a costly quarantine facility" no navio de resgate. Também ficou combinado que os astronautas passariam "three weeks in isolation" antes de abraçar a família.
Como três semanas são 21 dias, a alternativa E resume o desfecho: equipamento de quarentena e isolamento de 21 dias.
As demais não correspondem ao texto: o oxigênio era um risco imaginado da contaminação, não algo a garantir; a NASA não rejeitou as recomendações; a relutância não colocou vidas em risco; e os 1% de incerteza foram levados a sério.
Alternativa E.
Por que as outras alternativas estão erradas
- AO oxigênio aparece como risco hipotético de a vida extraterrestre consumi-lo, não como algo a garantir aos astronautas.
- BA NASA acabou concordando com as medidas mais rígidas, em vez de rejeitá-las publicamente.
- CA relutância existiu, mas a NASA adotou a quarentena e não há menção a risco de vida dos astronautas.
- DO cientista disse que 1% de incerteza era grande demais para ser ignorado; o risco não foi descartado.
Assunto: Informações explícitas e detalhes.
Reportar erro na resolução
Ver como caiu na prova
Fonte: Einstein 2023 · Prova I. Prova oficial ↗